Manufactured Stone vs.
Brick
It is difficult to compare cast stone to brick, simply because
they are different products. It is much like trying to
compare stucco and vinyl siding. For the most part, it is
simply a matter of personal preference. Often, brick and
engineered stone are used in conjunction, producing a stunning
and elegant effect.
In comparing the price of brick to
engineered stone, the
stone is usually more expensive than brick, for a couple of
reasons:
- Brick is mass produced in automated plants, but fake
stone
is hand-crafted. Manual production, with an eye for
the finished product is required to duplicate the detailed
coloring and texture of natural stone.
- Bricks are all the same size and laid in courses, so the
installation is highly repetitious. Exterior
stone is
installed in more random patterns, with careful attention to
duplicate the look of hand laid natural stone. This
involves color and size selection of each stone and laying
the stone in a manner that is appropriate for the style
being used.
There are some factors that can affect the price. In
new construction, if it is know beforehand where the concrete stone
will be used, the brick ledge on the footings may not be
required, depending on local building codes, which should always
be consulted. Brick requires structural support running
down to the foundation of the house. Manufactured stone,
because of its lighter weight and the manner in which it is
installed, doesn't require this additional support and
expense. For example, dormers and fireplace chases can be
covered with manufactured stone as long as there is a
structurally sound substrate, such as framing over which to
install.
Manufactured Stone vs. Natural Stone
Natural stone can be beautiful and there are applications where
it is the material of choice. However, it is generally
quite expensive, especially if the style and color of stone you
want is not indigenous to your area. The installed cost of
natural stone is often twice the cost of manufactured stone, due
to the cost of quarrying, shipping and installing natural
stone. Also, there is often a lot of waste material with
natural stone installation, depending on the style.
There are also other cost factors to consider. Natural
stone usually requires larger footings, generally at least 6 to
8 inches of ledge, depending on the type of stone you are
installing. Without adequate footings, natural stone can
settle. A local homeowner called us to come install
manufactured stone for a fireplace surround. The previous
owner had installed natural stone over a wood sub-floor and
crawl space, but without installing additional structural
support. The wood flooring in the living room was starting
to rise and buckle due to the weight of the stone, which had to
be torn out and removed. We replaced the masonry with cast
stone. The homeowner was relieved to correct the
structural problems and preferred the appearance of the cast
stone, which was selected to reflect the color and style of the
home.
Besides cost, there are other advantages to manufactured
stone. One is its versatility, since it can be installed
in places where natural stone would require structural footings
or piers. This includes interior applications, where it
can be used for columns, walls, fireplace surrounds or to dress
up kitchen islands or backsplashes. Cast stone gives you
the ability to select specific color and texture combinations
that enhance the beauty of your home. We offer a variety of
products including cobblestone, limestone and river rock.
|